The progressive movement had also pressured the government to preserve democracy, promote social justice and ensure security for all Americans Oakes et al. Both the Progressives and the New Dealers shared a belief in the possibility that government could promote and speed social improvement.
InJohnson won election as mayor of Cleveland on a platform of just taxation, home rule for Ohio cities, and a 3-cent streetcar fare.
Chief among these aims was the pursuit of trust busting, the breaking up very large monopolies, and support for labor unions, public health programs, decreased corruption in politics, and environmental conservation.
After in-depth surveys, local and even state governments were reorganized to reduce the number of officials and to eliminate overlapping areas of authority between departments. For the Progressives, the threat came from violent and revolutionary anarchism; for the New Dealers, from reactionary nationalist movements like those that emerged in Italy and Germany.
The two movements were different in that one was a conscious movement toward a booming economy, The Progressive Movement, while the other was a response to a crashing and poor time, The New Deal.
The country was being improved while people were making money. The solution to purifying the vote included prohibition designed to close down the saloonsvoter registration requirements designed to end multiple votingand literacy tests designed to minimize the number of ignorant voters.
But it also included efforts to coerce immigrants into assimilating into American society. An expert on the subject, Michael Kazin, offers the following definition for this political impulse: One of the most apparent legacies of the Progressive Era left to American education was the perennial drive to reform schools and curricula, often as the product of energetic grass-roots movements in the city.
Indeed, they sought to reform capitalism so that it would not be replaced by radical alternatives. In the end, the differences between the New Deal and Progressivism are no less important than the similarities. As much as the two movements have similarities, the new dealers were not just a mere continuation of the progressives.
The New Dealers also pursued a foreign policy that differed in important ways from that of the Progressive. For the army and navy to suceed abroad, mass production f war materials had to be centrally planned, and only the federal government could fulfill this role.
So much so that liberals like Hilary Clinton are being forced to talk of themselves as progressives.
Historians of educational reform during the Progressive Era tend to highlight the fact that many progressive policies and reforms were very different and, at times, even contradictory.
Some things never change. The New Deal was a government plan that helped the people. The architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright soared, John Dewey explored the library catalog system, and Wilson spoke of a new government. Urged on by severe economic distress and the looming threat of social unrest, both progressives and New Dealers sought to reform American capitalism.
By the s many progressives abandoned liberal conservationism for radical environmentalism, which seeks to protect nature by separating it from humanity and industry.
They despised the nouveau riche of the Gilded Age, but also tended to view European immigrants and white and black Southerners as benighted primitives.
The close cooperation between industry and government produced efficiency, but did not ignore the interests of workers. And whatever they were, what was their motivation?. Progressives versus New Dealers Essay by scout, University, Bachelor's, B- June download word file, 5 pages download word file, 5 pages 0 votes.
Progressives and New Dealers From the Revised Framework: Read the essay comparing Progressive reform to the New Deal. Highlight main ideas. Then finish your Venn Diagram on page 1 of this activity.
During the New Deal, many government planners and leaders drew inspiration for. New Dealers also found in the Progressive movement an example of gradual reform through democratic institutions. In addition, the Progressives had insisted upon the need for government to promote social justice, to preserve democracy, and to provide security to Americans, all principles that New Dealers championed as well.
Compare and contrast the Progressive Era (), the Roaring Twenties (s), and the New Deal Era (s) according to three of the following: the cultural activities, political leadership, economic conditions, and/or international involvements that characterized each era.
The Populists and Progressives saw numerous economic, political, and social problems in need of reform%(3). Progressives, New Dealers, and the Politics of Landscape by Michael Lind 08/11/ One of the greatest ironies of our time is the fact that today’s leading progressives tend to despise the very decentralized landscape that an earlier generation of New Deal liberals created.
New Dealers compared/contrasted to the Progressives. Name: Course: Lecturer: Date: New vs.
Progressives Dealers In the era of the New Deal, most of the government planners involved had been inspired by the policies and reforms of the Progressive era.Progressives versus new dealers essay